The Law on Energy Transition: the impact on insurance companies

Key Takeaways:
  • Article 173 of the Law on Energy Transition requires that French insurance companies publish a report on the manner in which they assess risks relating to ESG issues, in particular the climate.
  • For insurance companies, climate change means a greater risk of natural disasters to insure against, coupled with a potentially unsustainable increase in the price of insurance premium for the insured persons and, finally, a risk on the value of their investments.
  • The most advanced insurance companies have gone beyond the “Best in class” SRI, exclusion and core/satellite approach, and made the climate one of the key focuses of their investment policy.
Estelle Castres,

Head of Key Insurance Clients Group Natixis Investment Managers

Hervé Guez,

Global Head of Research and CIO of Equities & Fixed Income Mirova

What measures have you taken to adapt your investments to the fight against climate change? This is the key question that must be answered by French institutional investors subject to Article 173 of the Law on Energy Transition voted by the French Parliament, and in particular insurance companies. “This legislation requires investors to publish a report on the manner in which they assess risks relating to environment, social and governance (ESG) subjects, but with a specific focus on climate issues as this law was introduced in response to the COP 21 held in Paris that year (in 2015)”, stresses Hervé Guez, Head of Research and Equities & Fixed Income at Mirova (an affiliate of Natixis Investment Managers dedicated to sustainable investment).

Insurance companies called upon to keep pace with the energy transition

The first reports by French investors relating to Article 173 were published in the summer of 2017. Certain reports were harshly criticised by observers, such as the French entity of the WWF, for the lack of clarity in information provided by insurance companies. Is this a case of France lagging the field? Not really, quite the contrary, this French legislation was quite innovative. Put into perspective on an international scale, we have seen an acceleration in the political agenda relating to the urgency of climate issues and an increasing number of incentives targeting the financial sector, with events such as Climate Finance Day. An increasing number of regulators are following in the footsteps of France and are seeking to align investments with the energy transition. Certain countries in Asia-Pacific such as Australia and Japan are already ahead of the game with others, such as South Korea and Singapore, slightly behind but hot on their heels.

And yet, addressing the urgency of climate issues comes naturally to insurance companies, which are built around risk management. First and foremost, climate change means a greater risk of natural disasters, disasters which they are required to insure against. And their cost is rising. In terms of hurricanes, 2017 was one of the most destructive seasons ever seen, with 21 billion dollars of damage in the United States caused by three category four hurricanes (Irma, Harvey and Maria) according to Swiss Re, the global reinsurance leader. As Henri de Castries pointed out a few years ago, a world where the temperature increases by four degrees is not insurable. If climate risk is therefore a systemic risk, insurance companies which are not correctly prepared would expose themselves to double punishment: an increase in the physical risks they must insure against, coupled with a potentially unsustainable increase in the price of insurance premium for the insured person and a risk on the value of their investments. We must also consider stranded assets: if a share of fossil fuel reserves were subject to a mining ban, this would have a major negative impact on the valuation of the shares and the credit quality of the companies in question.

Going beyond regulatory requirements and placing ESG at the heart of its investment strategy

What can asset managers do to support insurance companies in the necessary transition of their investments? “As a group with several affiliates that have an ESG filter, including Mirova which is entirely dedicated to sustainable investment, we have worked extensively with our insurance company clients on this subject” explains Estelle Castres, Head of Key Insurance Clients Group at Natixis Investment Managers. “Each client is unique. First, we discuss with each one, both broadly and in depth, their exposure to climate issues, before proposing tailor-made sustainable investment solutions.” “Insurance companies need to ask themselves what climate risks means for them, to define a scenario and set targets” explains Hervé Guez. “This allows us to discuss fairly technical subjects with them, such as the correlation between financial performance and climate risk. The provision of an intellectual capital is key at this stage”.

The core/satellite approach is well suited to climate issues

Insurance companies can take a step forward in their risk management through their core/satellite approach: the climate risk approach can thus be implemented across the entire portfolio, economically and with a limited tracking error. ESG criteria can be used for scoring purposes for the portfolio’s core segment. In the satellite segment, insurance companies can integrate solutions with greater social or environmental impacts, invest in open-ended funds carrying the French SRI or TEEC (Transition Energétique et Ecologique pour le Climat - Energy and Ecological Transition for Climate Change) label or in illiquid assets via equity investments. Climate risk measurement may thus lead an insurance company to modify its asset allocation.

The most advanced insurance companies in terms of strategic thinking and the transfer of their climate-related beliefs to their investments have gone beyond the “Best in class” SRI, exclusion and core/satellite approach, and made the climate issue one of the key focuses of their investment policy in a holistic manner.

And although this subject remains in its early stages in certain countries, Estelle Castres confirms that there is a widespread desire among European insurance companies to go further than simply excluding certain sectors from their investments. The European Commission’s action plan promoting sustainable finance - which is based on the final recommendations set out by the High-Level Expert Group on sustainable finance, of which Philippe Zaouati, CEO of Mirova and Chair of Finance for Tomorrow, was a member - clarifies, in particular, the duty of asset managers and institutional investors to take sustainability into account in the investment process and enhance disclosure requirements. This proves that French legislation has inspired European regulations. The rationale behind the energy transition is going strong, despite the US setback following the United States’ withdrawal from the Paris agreement, and it is in insurance companies’ interest to take the lead rather than be overtaken by the masses.

The more advanced insurance companies ensure that the climate footprint of their investments are in line with the climate path of +2°C set out in the Paris agreements. “We believe that a quick-fix approach limited to just removing a few major direct emitters of carbon from our portfolios is inadequate” explains Hervé Guez. “Carbon risk is not limited to a few coal-fired plants and we must analyse the direct and indirect footprint of each sector”.

Insurance companies which address this issue can expect to have a real impact on the climate, by systematically taking ESG criteria into account in their investments or by offering their own clients financial products which clearly show their commitment to the climate. French and European savings can thus be steered towards green and socially responsible products. This is the aim of the creation of a European label for green financial products based on a system for classifying green assets.

Natixis Investment Managers and Mirova strive to support insurance companies in their overall reflection on factoring ESG, and in particular environmental, criteria into their strategy as the climate is a major issue which goes beyond the scope of compliance with regulatory requirements.

Published in September 2018

Affiliate of Natixis Investment Managers
Limited liability company
Share Capital: €8 322 490
Regulated by the Autorité des Marchés Financiers (AMF) under n° GP 02014.
RCS Paris n° 394 648 216
59 avenue Pierre Mendès France

Natixis Investment Managers
RCS Paris 453 952 681
Share Capital: €178 251 690
43 avenue Pierre Mendès France
75013 Paris

This communication is for information only and is intended for investment service providers or other Professional Clients. The analyses and opinions referenced herein represent the subjective views of the author as referenced unless stated otherwise and are subject to change. There can be no assurance that developments will transpire as may be forecasted in this material.

Copyright © 2018 Natixis Investment Managers S.A – All rights reserved

Macro and Markets Overview

VIDEO (34’43) – Vincent Chailley, CIO and portfolio Manager, H2O Asset Management

Enhanced Beta Video

Ostrum AM is used his long standing expertise in managing fixed income products and developed his enhanced beta strategies which combines the advantages of the active management and the smart beta approach.

Buy and maintain,

A bold alternative to ‘buy and hold’ for fixed income

Emerging Equities

Ostrum AM focuses on stockpicking and avoids market “noise”.

Energy Transition

Renewable energy is one of the fastest growing segment within the infrastructure market


The Blockchain is on the verge of revolutionising asset management

What is natural capital?

VIDEO (3’19) – Gautier Quéru, Director of the Land Degradation Neutrality Fund Project at Mirova

Aviation Letter

Annual outlook of aircraft industry

2018 Market Outlook

Natixis Investment Managers’ affiliates share their thoughts on what might be on the horizon for investors in 2018.

Indices in Hot Water

The carbon footprint of the major equity indices exceeds the +2°C objective of the Paris Climate Agreement (COP 21).

US Municipal Bonds

Non-US investors could benefit from allocating to US municipal bonds

Finance and climate change

French institutional investors are bound by the Energy transition law to take action.

Aviation Letter

Annual outlook of aircraft industry

French Election

What does the outcome mean for global financial markets?

It’s Time for Real Assets

Private debt can be a lower-risk, higher-yielding alternative to traditional bonds

Real Estate Debt

An alternative to conventional fixed income investments

Green Bond Principles

Mirova discusses market standards and the lack of a regulatory body for Green Bonds

Real Estate Alchemy

Transforming non-core assets into prime property requires skill and resources

Referendum in Italy

Our expert’s insights into the 4th December's Italian referendum and its impact on financial markets.

Crisis Alpha

Managed futures may provide shelter from storms and diversified returns in calm markets

Active Share

How passive is your active manager?

Hop Aboard the U.S Growth Engine

Mid-market private companies have the potential to expand rapidly while avoiding high exposure to volatile public markets

2016 Global Retirement Index

4 key trends shaping the future of retirement security: access, incentives, engagement and economics.

Insurance Survey:

companies grapple with new regulatory constraints, capital rules and increased risks

Diversified Growth Funds

Seeking to respond to rapid shifts in markets while reducing risk.

Institutional Investors Outlook:

Institutional investors bullish on stocks, alternatives in 2016, wary of global political tensions